What did you do at your reloading bench today?

[Ernie]

Want to load some Berry's FP 158 gr heavy plated bullets rated 1500 fps with H110 for 357 mag practice. 15.6 grains in Hornandy manual says 1250 fps but Hogdon says 15.0 grains will produce 1480 fps. Any experience out there?

[DsGrouse]

What were the listed barrel lengths for the loads

[Ernie]

What were the listed barrel lengths for the loads

Hogdon 2025 book. Pistol data, no barrel length specified.
I will figure this out.
Thanks

[Mags]

....
The online Hodgdon reload center lists this in a 10" barrel.

Screenshot 2025-09-28 092400.png (98.62 KiB) Viewed 71 times

[Ernie]

Yep, that is pretty much what the book says. Lyman 16.3 grains 1178 fps. Nosler 14.9 1460 fps. Hornandy 15.6 1250 fps. I will load some starting around 14.0 and see what I get. Just thought I would ask if anyone had any experience with H110 using 158 gr bullets In 357 mag.
I have a lot of H110. I ordered 2 lbs and received 5 lbs. Offered to send it back but Hogdon told me to "keep it and thanks for tell us where it went".

[DsGrouse]

What were the listed barrel lengths for the loads

Hogdon 2025 book. Pistol data, no barrel length specified.
I will figure this out.
Thanks

I bet one is gor pistol le gth barrels ie the 10" and the other is carbine length

[Mags]

What were the listed barrel lengths for the loads

Hogdon 2025 book. Pistol data, no barrel length specified.
I will figure this out.
Thanks

I bet one is for pistol length barrels ie the 10" and the other is carbine length

...
The fps is quite a bit higher for carbine 18.5".

Screenshot 2025-09-28 092039.png (73.23 KiB) Viewed 46 times

[CT_Shooter]

Yep, that is pretty much what the book says. Lyman 16.3 grains 1178 fps. Nosler 14.9 1460 fps. Hornandy 15.6 1250 fps. I will load some starting around 14.0 and see what I get. Just thought I would ask if anyone had any experience with H110 using 158 gr bullets In 357 mag.
I have a lot of H110. I ordered 2 lbs and received 5 lbs. Offered to send it back but Hogdon told me to "keep it and thanks for tell us where it went".

Early in my shooting career (scant more than a decade ago), I looked for a single load that I could use in both my Big Boy and my SmokeWagon revolver. I'm just a plinker, so my only considerations were that it worked well in both guns and was accurate. Since then I've shot a few thousand of them. It's a mild load by anybody's standards, but I don't want to beat up the guns or myself. I just want to have fun shooting. It's accurate in my Big Boy out to 50 yds.

13.9 grains of H110 / 158 grain jsp or jhp bullet (Zero).

357 Handloads 072720.jpg (189.46 KiB) Viewed 37 times

BBB 357 Bench Rest 50 yards.jpg (77.12 KiB) Viewed 37 times

[DsGrouse]

Hogdon 2025 book. Pistol data, no barrel length specified.
I will figure this out.
Thanks

I bet one is for pistol length barrels ie the 10" and the other is carbine length

...
The fps is quite a bit higher for carbine 18.5".

Screenshot 2025-09-28 092039.png

The data and load numbers wdre from two different manuals... thats why i suspect the difference

[Ernie]

Yep, that is pretty much what the book says. Lyman 16.3 grains 1178 fps. Nosler 14.9 1460 fps. Hornandy 15.6 1250 fps. I will load some starting around 14.0 and see what I get. Just thought I would ask if anyone had any experience with H110 using 158 gr bullets In 357 mag.
I have a lot of H110. I ordered 2 lbs and received 5 lbs. Offered to send it back but Hogdon told me to "keep it and thanks for tell us where it went".

Early in my shooting career (scant more than a decade ago), I looked for a single load that I could use in both my Big Boy and my SmokeWagon revolver. I'm just a plinker, so my only considerations were that it worked well in both guns and was accurate. Since then I've shot a few thousand of them. It's a mild load by anybody's standards, but I don't want to beat up the guns or myself. I just want to have fun shooting. It's accurate in my Big Boy out to 50 yds.

13.9 grains of H110 / 158 grain jsp or jhp bullet (Zero).

Thank You. That is exactly the information I was looking for.