Les,
Just need to comment being a nutso firearms cleaning nut. I try out quite a few of the items that other Folk have tried. I have one qualification. The Folk need to share convincing positive evals tied to their cleaning experiences. That's what I look for.
Your hesitancy in your last statement is why I'm posting. I probably wouldn't try this product, as the design purpose was to combat (pun intended) the fine sands that went along with Desert Shield. I don't face that issue at all here in KC.
Sometimes even a highly recommended product doesn't work for me. There were some good posts/chats on our Forum re. Ballistol, and the excellent CLP that people found it to be. I was surprised that it didn't work for me, and I seldom use it now. I'll finish the bottle I have, but will buy no more. Another Forum chat was on how good Sea Foam products are. I checked it out at a local auto shop here, "Auto Zone," and read very little on the can's label re. gun cleaning. Guns were listed as one of the many products this could be used for, but was low on the listed items. There were listed mostly auto/truck parts, tools, hinges and moving metal parts frozen up by rust, etc. Honestly I don't know why, but I decided to try it.
At the moment (that may change with the wind), this
Sea Foam Deep Creep is the best gun cleaner I have in my cleaning box! My shotgun barrel is a real bear to clean, especially getting the shot shell plastic out. When I used Deep Creep to clean the barrel this week, it did a great job for me. It has been a long time since I've seen the shiny, mirror-like bore I looked at this go-around. For me, it was a great shotgun cleaning job that ended up the way I wanted it to! I'll continue to use Deep Creep...until the next super product appears.
I think you may have already answered your Q when you said "I don't think it's any better than....." Also you haven't yet found anyone near you that has used it. That seems to say something, as well. So I'd go with your kneejerk reaction....unless you bring a lot of sand into the house in your shoes.
Thanks for letting me spout on very little.