I like both, but option 3 was looking good to me so I went out this morning and played with the parts. I took the larger piece of wood and put it on the bottom, but it was CENTER drilled for the top.

But wait, I had the jeweler's bow saw. I took one side loose, fed it thru the center hole and cut a slot. This allowed that larger wood piece to move more to the side on the guard.
28 to move to option 3.jpg
Now we are cooking with gas. I marked it and shaped it on the disk sander. Oh yeah. Looks like option three is the winner. I fit all the pieces and parts in place, used the awl to mark the G10 pieces and rough shaped them on the disc sander. After a break, I'll go back out and polish the wood piece to about 600, then glue it up. Then I can start more formal shaping, polishing, and finishing.
29 option 3 it is.jpg
Miss T said it's fine, but the WOOD portion needs to be blended down to the guard, and the G10 pieces need to be blended smoothly into the stag.

Well duh... this is the rough assembly. She was sewing a quilt together... I DIDN'T say, "All those ragged edges need to be trimmed..."
There were sharp scissors and scalpels laying all over the Sew Shed. I may be old, but I'm not slow.

You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.